Embarrassed and Ashamed ~ How Does One “Defend” a Violent Occupation?

Sign at Demonstration
against Assult on Gaza
Photo Credit: Tina

It’s a tired old mantra that must be retired. We have heard it over and over again ~ how many times in these past days? I have lost count! We know it by heart, “Israel has the right to defend itself.” ~ Given that I am a citizen of two countries that have recited this tired, old mantra ad nauseam, I am compelled to share an alternative view. It will not appear “balanced,” but then neither is this conflict. But I must speak because, in the words of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., “our lives begin to end the day we become silent about the things that matter.” And this matters ~ I am embarrassed and ashamed of both Canada and the United States. The question as to which “side” started this most recent round of violence is really of little concern in this ongoing 45 year old conflict between Israel and Palestine. It’s not about who fired what where. It’s about Israel’s military occupation of Palestinian land and lives.

Gaza Demonstration ~ Al Ma’sara Village
Photo Credit: Dawn

Noam Chomsky says it well: “When Israelis in the occupied territories now claim that they have to defend themselves, they are defending themselves in the sense that any military occupier has to defend itself against the population they are crushing. You can’t defend yourself when you’re militarily occupying someone else’s land. That’s not defense. Call it what you like, it’s not defense.” ~ “Israel uses sophisticated attack jets and naval vessels to bomb densely-crowded refugee camps, schools, apartment blocks, mosques, and slums to attack a population that has no air force, no air defense, no navy, no heavy weapons, no artillery units, no mechanized armor, no command in control, no army… and calls it a war. It is not a war, it is murder.”

Soldier at Gaza Demonstration ~ Al Ma’sara
Photo Credit: Dawn

How I wish my president and my prime minster had the insight and courage to make such a statement ~ or to say something even approaching this level of honest engagement. Instead I read that Obama has pledged to give an additional $70 million in military aid to Israel in addition to the $3 billion annual gift. I am embarrassed and ashamed ~ Predictably, Harper proclaimed his unambiguous support for Israel’s ongoing attack on the people of Gaza. And we know that Canada is “Israel’s best friend.” But you would think that a best friend has certain responsibilities ~ the responsibility to call their friend to account for gross violations of international law and human rights for starters. I am embarrassed and ashamed.

Palestinians Queue to Go to Work in Israel
Checkpoint 300 ~ Bethlehem
Photo Credit: Dawn

I am embarrassed and ashamed at the silence and timidity of my church ~ the United Church of Canada. Rather than standing in the great prophetic tradition and calling on Israel to heed their own prophets’ call for justice, our moderator has invited us to pray. Could it be that we are called to be the answer to our own prayers by using our voices and our feet and our votes in the service of a just peace? Can we summon the courage to speak truth to power ~ to stand with the oppressed ~ to rally for justice ~ rather than sit passively by and pray for someone else to do it? Would that we might respond as Isaiah did: “Here I am, send me!” It is no longer faithful to pass off our responsibility to some higher power. I am embarrassed and ashamed.

Refugee Camp Youth Protest Gaza Assault
Separation Wall outside Our Home ~ Bethlehem
Photo Credit: Dawn

In the words of Rabbi Brant Rosen: “When will we be ready to accept that this is not a ‘balanced’ conflict or even a ‘war’ by any reasonable definition – and that it never was?  When will we face the painful truth that this is not a story about one side versus the other but about one side oppressing the other? Frankly, the well-meaning liberal comments about ‘praying for peace on both sides’ leave me cold. Worse, I find them insidious because they simply serve to support the myth that this is a conflict between two equal parties. It is not. And peace will not come until we admit this – until we admit that there is an essential injustice at the heart of this tragedy and that try as it might, Israel will never be able to make it go away through the sheer force of its increasingly massive military might.”

Sewage Water Shot at Demonstrators
(Teargas was also used)
Bethlehem Protest against Gaza Assault
Photo Credit: Anne

With everyone in the region, EAPPI teams in the West Bank breathed a sigh of relief and gratitude that Egypt brokered a ceasefire. But will it hold? And for how long? When will the next match light the still smoldering embers? ~ It seems clear that we cannot wait for heads of state or heads of churches to provide real leadership. The outcry needs to come from the global community ~ from civil society ~ from congregations ~ from us ~ Another way is possible ~ Could it be that “we are the ones we have been waiting for”*?

*Note: This quote is usually attributed to June Jordan from her “Poem for South African Women,” presented at the United Nations on August 9, 1978 in “commemoration of the 40,000 women and children who, August 9, 1956, presented themselves in bodily protest against the ‘dompas’ in the capital of apartheid.”

For excellent resources and links to alternative media on Gaza and the current situation in Palestine and Israel, please see the blog of my EAPPI colleague, Sherry Ann, who served in occupied East Jerusalem from the first week of Dec 2010 to the first week of March 2011.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to Embarrassed and Ashamed ~ How Does One “Defend” a Violent Occupation?

  1. Carey Wagner says:

    Thank you Dawn for your voice of solidarity – Be well and be safe – May Peace come out of your truth telling.

  2. Regina Lark says:

    Your photos look like mine when I was there June ’08. When I first arrived in Bethlehem and read the graffiti – colorfully and profoundly scrawled across the wall of separation – I choked-down a sob and wondered, how can anyone defend this occupation? There is so much sadness in me to see that nothing has changed in some ways and have gotten worse in others.

  3. Shelagh says:

    Dawn, the message is getting out! The Edmonton Journal had a political cartoon. Israel was a huge giant with armor, and Gaza was a little child with a pea shooter. Egypt was holding Gaza’s hand. It said it all! I know I have written to both the Prime Minister and President that terror comes in many forms. The destroying of people’s livelihood by uprooting their olive trees, destroying their homes, refusing to let them move freely in their own country, and restricting water resources, etc. is terror. Palestine has a right to defend itself!!!
    I am still appalled at how they spout the Israeli mantra when there are even Jewish folks and Rabbis appalled at Israel. The lobby, however, when the UC was making its decision on settlement products, was incredible considering I recieved three letters and I am not even in active ministry. So we know why they are spouting this rubbish. Thank heavens for political cartoonists.


  4. Marianna Harris says:

    Thanks so much for this. I’m forwarding it widely. Well said. Marianna Harris

  5. Kimberly Roy says:

    Thank you so much for your powerful words. It is a hard message to hear and to get others to listen to. Know you are not alone in your feelings 😦
    Hugs dear friend.

  6. Betty Marlin says:

    Powerful Dawn,

    Thank you for putting into words my and I am sure many peoples thoughts and feelings exactly. How painful it must be to be there right now.


  7. Audrey brooks says:

    I cannot believe that Israel would do the same thing to the Palestinians as was done to them in the Holocaust! There could be peace if they really really wanted to have a just peace wth land, water and safety for both sides. Instead they have used the guilt of the Holocaust to bring other governments onside to their cause, while using the same media blitz as the Nazis did to portray the people of Gaza as inferior, rabid terrorizers, and worthy of elimination because their very existence threatens both the people and the state of Israel. History is repeating istself. “Oh God, where are you? We go about in sadness while the enemy afflicts us.”

  8. Lynn Elliott says:

    Dawn, thank you for these powerful and meaningful words. I hear you and wish to cry out with you too… thank you also for naming the sense of embarassment for the UCC over the handling of this issue. I too have been saddened by the outcry and calls to reverse the decision because it went too far – it didn’t go far enough for some of us. Once again it feels like we missed our opportunity to be firm in our prophetic tradition and take a stand for true justice. And somehow we still believe in the UCC that we don’t want to hurt anyone’s feelings. Take good care good woman!

  9. Spoken well! Thanks be! Will sing songs of hope with you!

  10. Chris Mann says:

    Thank you for these reports and photos – to have someone as sensitive and wise as you in such a troubled area of the world is a gift to all of us, because we can all learn through your experiences. I really appreciate the work you are doing and send prayers for peace for all….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s